Before the modernistic geological era of superhero film , it was unthinkable for performers like Michael Keaton — who play Batman in two Tim Burton - direct films — to deliver to the big screen as a Marvel character . That ’s for the most part because Marvel picture show were rarely a big deal before the turn of the hundred . Since the launch of the MCU in 2008 , Keaton , and his Batman successor , Christian Bale , have both crossed over to Marvel . Yet , neither of the two batman have had the wallop in Marvel ’s realm that Tom Hardy has had as Venom .
Hardy was cast as Bane inThe Dark Knight Risesopposite Bale ’s Batman in 2012 , before returning to the genre as the asterisk of Sony’sVenomin 2018 . The player returned for two sequels , including the late releasedVenom : The Last Dance , which seemingly wrapped up the title graphic symbol ’s write up . Now that Hardy has terminate his stint in Sony ’s nook of the Marvel multiverse , it ’s time to answer the doubtfulness of which villain he toy best : Venom or Bane ?
When considering the answer to that interrogative sentence , it should be remembered that Hardy is actually play two roles in the Venom moving-picture show , since he depict both Eddie Brock and voices the Venom symbiote in the Venom movies . to boot , the Brobdingnagian legal age of risible book motion-picture show rooter may not be cognisant that Venom was Spider - Man ’s greatest adversary before his popularity convinced Marvel to sour him into an antihero . While the characters are different , there are some comparisons we can make between Venom and Bane to help oneself determine which role Hardy was better in .
Need more recommendations ? Then check outthe upright superhero movies , rankings for all of Sony ’s Marvel movies , the secure Marvel Cinematic Universe sequels , andthe best non - Marvel superhero movies .
Physicality
Tom Hardy is generally in good physical condition in his films , but he ’s rarely bulked up to superhuman proportions in the means he did forThe Dark Knight Rises . Bane was introduced in the comic as one of the few scoundrel who could physically reign Batman in a fight , and he even broke Bruce Wayne ’s back in their initial throwdown . Hardy ’s physique in the movie gave Bane the credibility he needed even before his adaptation of the character mopped the story with Bale ’s Dark Knight .
The Venom films were n’t as reliant on Hardy ’s dead body to betray the illusion of the title character ’s metier and powers . CGI take care of most of that . Hardy is scarcely a slouch in those cinema , but he ’s not bigger than life like he was as Bane .
bound : nemesis
Characterization
Bane is an restrain comportment inThe Dark Knight Rises , and he ’s a very different scoundrel than Heath Ledger ’s Joker fromThe Dark Knight . However , Bane is n’t as fondly remember or as memorable as the Joker in part because he does n’t ultimately turn out to be the chief baddie of the moving-picture show . One of the big reveals inThe Dark Knight Risesis that Bane is bring under someone else to play their dream of vengeance to fruition . That ’s what makes Bane ’s final showdown with Batman sense like an undercard tear rather than the master result .
There ’s not a lot of depth to Bane , but there was a lot for Hardy to explore in the Venom movies . Eddie is a journalist who bust up his career and his relationship with his fiancée , Anne Weying ( Michelle Williams ) , ahead of time in the first picture . So the audience see Eddie at his miserable before he ’s bonded with Venom , which changes the form of both of their lives . The trilogy is the exploration of that bond and the ups and pile of the friendship they shared . Eddie and Venom are n’t always on the same page , but viewer were more invested in their characters than they were in Bane .
Edge : Venom
Voice
Neither Bane nor Venom sound like Hardy ’s normal speech production voice . He craft a high - lurch vocalisation and unmatched accent for Bane , which work well enough for the film . However , Hardy ’s Bane phonation has since become a author of unintended wit . For example , voice actor James Adomian utilise an impression of Hardy ’s Bane for the character in Max’sHarley Quinnanimated serial .
Hardy ’s voice as Venom is also a small unusual , but it does n’t lend itself to parody as much as his Bane emphasis did . There was also something endearing about the Venom voice that made it easy to block that Hardy was play off of himself in every conversation between Eddie and the symbiote . Venom and Eddie really seemed like two separate characters , and that would n’t have influence if Hardy could n’t differentiate the voices he pass on to both of them .
Story
There have been three Venom movies to date , and yet you ’d be hard - pressed to find any critic who would rank them among the best superhero movies ever . Audiences like Eddie and Venom , but the diminishing returns ofThe Last Dance‘s boxful business office intimate that fans are also somewhat over them . They ’re great characters who have been held back by lusterless movies , even though they get along a lot safe than other Spider - Man - adjacent characters likeMadame WebandMorbius .
The Dark Knight Risesis often considered to be behindThe Dark KnightandBatman Beginsin terms of quality . Director Christopher Nolan and his originative collaborators — as well as the all - star casts — set up a very high barroom with those first two films . The Dark Knight Risesmay not live up to its predecessors , but the film is miles forward of all three of the Venom moving picture aggregate .
Iconic status
Bane and Venom were both prominent comic Good Book villains in the early ’ 90s for Batman and Spider - Man , respectively . DC and Marvel ’s top paladin have very mysterious scalawag ’ veranda , yet few of the advanced creations have broken through like those two . Bane entered the pantheon of Batman ’s greatest bad cat and he has maintained his office there over 30 years after he was introduced .
However , Venom transcended his status as a baddie . The picture show may have skipped over this important part of his grapheme development , but there ’s no question that he ’s far more iconic than Bane . Could you picture comical book rooter delineate up for three Bane moving picture wheneven the Joker bumble with his sequel?The Last Dancemay be lagging behind its predecessor , but Venom still has three movies under his bash . That ’s a feat that Sony ’s unconvincing to repeat with Spider - Man ’s other villains .
With a mark of 3 - 2 , we ’re calling this contest in party favour of Venom over Bane .
